From humble beginnings and the Lord's blessings the present Lititz United Methodist Church came into existence. Approximately 1888 the Lititz mission charge was constituted. Then in 1890 a congregation formed, deciding to build a house of worship. Ground was purchased on North Cedar Street and an edifice was dedicated on December 20, 1891.

As a result of increasing membership ground was broken in 1933 for a sizable addition to be used by the Sunday School. The congregation continued to outgrow its structure and so the decision was made to relocate and build a new house of worship on the corner of East Market and New Street. This beautiful, new building was dedicated in March of 1972.

Still, with all of this, the continued growth precipitated the need for additional space. In 1995 the congregation voted to build an addition that would allow more space for education, fellowship, worship and office use. This addition was consecrated on June 29, 1997.